I Think I’ll Have My Own Opinion

. Reviewers.

I know reviewers are supposed to help make or break a book, and that good reviews are considered very important. I have to say though, as reader, I find reviews not very helpful at all.

They seem to fall into two categories. One is ‘all other books are bad and therefore this is good’. For example, if a book has a child as hero, you can guarantee that reviewers will say ‘better than Harry Potter!’. Usually it isn’t. Or it is such a different kind of book to Harry Potter than comparing it is like comparing apples to oranges, simply because they are both fruit. Crime books will say ‘better than Cornwell’,romance will say ‘better than Cookson!’.I find this kind of review quite nasty. It’s promoting one author at the expense of another, and is very negative.

Or the review is of the ‘best book of the 21st century’ type. As this is only 2011, this seems a bit ridiculous. Besides, I’ve read Victorian reviews of books that call them ‘best book of our time’, and almost invariably, that book is utterly forgotten.

I have to say I always end disagreeing utterly with reviewers (that tends to go for music, film and TV too). As a reader, I’ve found I prefer to make my own choice (and note to publishers – please replace that list of ecstatic reviews on the back of books with some hint of what the book is actually about). As a writer, I’m not going to worry what the reviewers think. The people who buy my books will be the important ones.


One response to “I Think I’ll Have My Own Opinion

  1. The problem as an author is how to get your book out there in a very competitive environment where the playing field is anything but level. Indie published and alternative books struggle to get noticed. The pundits say these authors should’ve waited. That the quality of Indie novels is poor. I’ve read a few novels cranked out by multi-published best selling authors that were garbage. At least one best selling author has a factory going. He has ghost writers cranking out numerous novels per year under his name.

    Many times the Indie novel is very good. It could not get published because it didn’t fit into the criteria that was trending at the moment.

    To a great extend, Indie authors rely on Amazon and Barnes & Noble reviews to get noticed at all.

    I write historical fiction (post WWII era) in the Christian market. My break out novel on Kindle, BURNING HEARTS, is a suspense, with a great deal of action and romance, as well as a healthy dose of humor. It’s Christian themed, but not preachy. It’s got Christian characters that are true to the way individuals behanved and interacted in that time period. Speaking of reviews. It got 10 five-star reviews on Amazon. If you’d like to take a look…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s